Recent Memoranda of Decision

Memoranda of decision are listed on this page for approximately 60-90 days after they are issued.

August 2018
Docket # Mem Dec # Case Title Date Decided Subject Trial Judge Result
BCD-17-536 Mem 18-69 Central Maine Drywall, Inc. v. Pro Con, Inc., et al. 8/9/18 Mechanic's lien Murphy Affirmed

 

July 2018
Docket # Mem Dec # Case Title Date Decided Subject Trial Judge Result
Ken-17-350 Mem 18-68 State of Maine v. Christopher Wilson 7/31/18 Aggrevated trafficking of cocaine base Stanfill Affirmed
Han-18-43 Mem 18-67 State of Maine v. Neil D. Salisbury 7/31/18 Operating after suspension Roberts Affirmed
Cum-17-542 Mem 18-66 Julie A. Burnell v. Todd J. Sullivan 7/31/18 Parental rights and responsibilities Darvin Affirmed
Ken-17-453 Mem 18-65 Horace Salley v. Department of Corrections 7/26/18 Prisoner mailbox rule Stokes Vacated
Cum-17-558 Mem 18-64 State of Maine v. Emil Dzabiev 7/26/18 Violating protection from harassmetn order L. Walker Affirmed
Pen-17-480 Mem 18-63 State of Maine v. Joseph Duquette Sr. 7/17/18 Domestic violence assault Anderson Affirmed
Han-17-471 Mem 18-62 Guardianship of Jake H. 7/12/18 De facto parentage Patterson Affirmed
Cum-17-519 Mem 18-61 Charles D. Clemetson v. Board of Licensure in Medicine et al. 7/3/18 License to practice medicine L. Walker Affirmed
Ken-17-513 Mem 18-60 Sharmila Das-Wattley v. Board of Podiatric Medicine 7/3/18 License to practice podiatry Murphy Affirmed
And-17-444 Mem 18-59 State of Maine v. Jacob R. Labbe 7/3/18 Violation of preconviction bail Lawrence Affirmed
Cum-17-511 Mem 18-58 James D. Klein et al. v. Mark C. Klein 7/3/18 Arbitration awards L. Walker Affirmed

 

June 2018
Docket # Mem Dec # Case Title Date Decided Subject Trial Judge Result
Yor-17-491 Mem 18-57 Helen R. Rose v. William Parsons Jr. et al. 6/28/18 Easement Douglas Affirmed
Ken-17-64 Mem 18-56 State of Maine v. Ralph E. Michaud Jr. 6/28/18 Gross sexual assault Mullen Affirmed
Yor-17-242 Mem 18-55 Richardson and Associates v. Patelli Group, LLC 6/21/18 Breach of contract Moskowitz Affirmed
Pen-17-374 Mem 18-54 Donald F. MacLeod v. Eastern Maine Healthcare Systems 6/21/18 Age discrimination A. Murray Affirmed
Ken-17-435 Mem 18-53 State of Maine v. Sarah B. Conway 6/21/18 Gross sexual assault Marden Affirmed
Pen-17-399 Mem 18-52 State of Maine v. Rodney O. Gaskell 6/19/18 Assault Anderson Affirmed
Han-17-429 Mem 18-51 Terrence E. Pinkham v. Department of Transportation 6/12/18 Eminent domain R. Murray Affirmed
Ken-17-505 Mem 18-50 Ellis Construction, Inc. v. Town of Farmingdale 6/12/18 Town contract Stokes Affirmed
Cum-17-504 Mem 18-49 Benjamin Guiliani Sr. v. Town of Bridgton 6/7/18 Dangerous property Mills Affirmed
BCD-17-376 Mem 18-48 Sherman Leighton et al. v. Fidelity National Title Group, Inc., et al. 6/7/18 Breach of contract Mulhern Affirmed
Han-18-21 Mem 18-47 Keith J. Paradis v. Jackie Doar 6/7/18 Child support Budd Affirmed
Ken-17-507 Mem 18-46 State of Maine v. Raymond J. Sudduth 6/7/18 OUI Murphy Affirmed
Pen-17-410 Mem 18-45 State of Maine v. Robert Caldwell 6/7/18 OUI Lucy Affirmed

 

May 2018
Docket # Mem Dec # Case Title Date Decided Subject Trial Judge Result
Lin-17-377 Mem 18-44 New England Receivables, LLC v. Robert W. Van Brunt 5/24/18 Credit card debt Worth Affirmed
WCB-17-146 Mem 18-43 Ronald E. Flanagin v. Department of Inland Fisheries & Wildlife 5/17/18 Workers compensation Jerome, ALJ Affirmed
Oxf-17-449 Mem 18-42 Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Clara Welch-Gallant 5/10/18 Foreclosure Beliveau Affirmed
Ken-18-150 Mem 18-41 Max P. Linn v. Secretary of State et al. 5/8/18 Nomination petitions Stokes Affirmed
Han-17-503 Mem 18-40 Snow Logan v. Paul E. Arnold 5/8/18 Motion to modify Roberts Affirmed
Kno-17-338 Mem 18-39 Steve Anctil v. Maine Department of Corrections 5/3/18 Motion to dismiss Sparaco Affirmed
Cum-17-420 Mem 18-38 Nathaniel Warren-White et al. v. Martina Sullivan 5/3/18 Adverse possession L. Walker Affirmed
Yor-17-551 Mem 18-37 Keith McKenna v. Ashley M Gagnon-Croteau 5/3/18 Modification of parental rights Janelle Affirmed
Aro-17-426 Mem 18-36 Marisa Levesque v. Corey White Sr. 5/3/18 Protection from abuse O'Mara Affirmed
Ken-17-422 Mem 18-35 State of Maine v. Kelly M. Goards 5/1/18 OUI Marden Affirmed
Was-17-348 Mem 18-34 Patricia A. Giero v. Richard A. Giero 5/1/18 Protection from abuse Budd Affirmed

 

April 2018
Docket # Mem Dec # Case Title Date Decided Subject Trial Judge Result
Lin-17-440 Mem 18-33 Kerry Emanuel et al. v. Town of Bristol et al. 4/26/18 Code enforcement Billings Affirmed
Ken-17-409 Mem 18-32 David Bordetsky v. JAK Realty Trust et al. 4/26/18 Foreclosure Mullen Affirmed
Was-17-454 Mem 18-31 State of Maine v. Ricky O. Millay 4/19/18 OUI Stewart Affirmed
Kno-17-379 Mem 18-30 Janet Emery et al. v. Laura Billings et al. 4/17/18 Prescriptive easements Mallonee Affirmed
Aro-17-397 Mem 18-29 Gerard Ouellette et al. v. Labonte Investment Realty, LLC 4/17/18 Ambiguous deeds Stewart Affirmed

March 2018
Docket # Mem Dec # Case Title Date Decided Subject Trial Judge Result
Ken-17-472 Mem 18-28 Rita A. Philbrook v. Scott Shepherd 3/29/18 Contempt E. Walker Affirmed
Yor-17-345 Mem 18-27 Sarah Breton v. Robert Raiten 3/27/18 Protection from abuse Driscoll Dismissed
Yor-17-305 Mem 18-26 Danielle Dillman v. William Godek 3/22/18 Protection from abuse Janelle Affirmed
Oxf-17-316 Mem 18-25 Gloria Carignan v. Paul R. Dumas Jr. 3/20/18 Right to access Clifford Affirmed
Pen-17-293 Mem 18-24 State of Maine v. Ryan T. Robinson 3/15/18 OUI Jordan Affirmed
Was-17-372 Mem 18-23 Machias Savings Bank v. Beth C. Hartford et al. 3/15/18 Foreclosure D. Mitchell Affirmed
Cum-17-296 Mem 18-22 State of Maine v. Ezra LeBlanc-Simpson 3/15/18 Reckless conduct with a dangerous weapon L. Walker Affirmed
Yor-17-302 Mem 18-21 Phillip Jordan v. Kathryn Slattery et al. 3/15/18 Sex offender registration O'Neil Affirmed
Wal-17-432 Mem 18-20 Ly T. Ha v. Jessie L. Adams 3/15/18 Modification of parental rights Worth Affirmed
Yor-17-327 Mem 18-19 Edmund J. Dunne v. Elizabeth A. (Dunne) Woodbury 3/15/18 Divorce Cantara Affirmed

Cum-17-346 Cum-17-355 Cum-17-356

Mem 18-18 Roy A. Day v. Lorna R. Grey et al. 3/15/18 Amendment of complaint L. Walker Affirmed
Ken-17-395 Mem 18-17 State of Maine v Daniel R. MacQueen 3/6/18 Speeding Fowle Affirmed
Was-17-320 Mem 18-16 Wilmington Trust, National Association v. Terri L. Brown et al. 3/6/18 Foreclosure Romei Affirmed
Ken-17-209 Mem 18-15 Heather Skolfield v. Daniel Morrill 3/6/18 Protection from abuse E. Walker Affirmed
Kno-17-336 Mem 18-14 Earl Gammon et al. v. Robin E. Boggs et al. 3/6/18 Post judgment order Stokes Dismissed
Yor-17-335 Mem 18-13 Danny C. Brown II v. Jason A. Bean 3/6/18 Protection from harassment Foster Affirmed

February 2018
Docket # Mem Dec # Case Title Date Decided Subject Trial Judge Result
Cum-17-253 Mem 18-12 State of Maine v. Barre F. Hersi 2/27/18 Operating after habitual offender revocation Warren Affirmed
Cum-17-317 Mem 18-11 Diane L. Churchill v. Paragon Commercial Real Estate, LLC, et al. 2/27/18 Breach of contract L. Walker Affirmed
Sag-17-229 Mem 18-10 State of Maine v. Prescott E. McCurdy 2/22/18 Violation of a protection order Billings Affirmed